Visitor
abodas
Posts: 2
Registered: ‎03-17-2004
Coax or Cat-5 Installation?
Hi All
I recently got Uverse installed and technician used Coax. My house is pre-wired for both Coax and CAT-5. Which is better to use? Can I ask them to re-do the connection to Cat-5. I did not get their VOIP service? Is there a benefit in getting that?
 
Thanks
Guru
hogrunr
Posts: 4,989
Registered: ‎08-08-2006
Re: Coax or Cat-5 Installation?
As long as your coax is in good condition, it will ultimately give a little more bandwidth than cat 5. So you should be ok.
spd2demun
Posts: 22,101
Kudos: 376
Registered: ‎07-28-2007
My Device: ♥ U-verse! NOT~AN~EMPLOYEE!
Re: Coax or Cat-5 Installation?
Was there a reason they didn't use the Cat5 if it was already there?
 
They can most likely rewire you to the Cat5, but they'll probably charge you for that.
 
As far as which is better, I think the jury is still out. :smileywink:
 
VoIP is not available in all areas yet.  No advantage other than combining costs on the UV bill.  Right now VoIP is the same price as their landline (with same features except onscreen Caller ID).  Just depends on what you want or need in a home phone.
*The views and opinions expressed on this forum are purely my own. Any product claim, statistic, quote, or other representation about a product or service should be verified with the manufacturer, provider, or party.
Visitor
elob9
Posts: 25
Registered: ‎12-17-2007
Re: Coax or Cat-5 Installation?
the benifit of using cat5 is for future up grading and its faster to trouble shoot ( no spliters all ran to the rg in most cases) coax is half duplex cat5 is full duplex, the coax would have alot of collisions. computer networks years ago used them
spd2demun
Posts: 22,101
Kudos: 376
Registered: ‎07-28-2007
My Device: ♥ U-verse! NOT~AN~EMPLOYEE!
Re: Coax or Cat-5 Installation?
Everytime I say Cat5 is better, I get yelled at by people who have coax and have *no problems*.:smileysad:  And in my experience, coax has caused nothing but problems.  My choice would be Cat5, but I didn't get a choice...
*The views and opinions expressed on this forum are purely my own. Any product claim, statistic, quote, or other representation about a product or service should be verified with the manufacturer, provider, or party.
Professor
randyl
Posts: 8,146
Registered: ‎10-25-2007
Re: Coax or Cat-5 Installation?
HomePNA 3.0 (128 Mbps) - Ethernet adapter (4 ports 10/100 Base-TX)
 
elob hpna v3 is not the same as your older t- base  btw
 
if u guys are gonna knock it maybe u should read up on it and  get your ducks in a row :smileytongue:)
 
if we had collisions on the backfeed i guess we would all be ripping out coax lol
 
the tranmission (coax)  is bi-directional at diff frequency is all ..  (why  the rg6 from nid to rg3800 is fine)
 
did your speed and house run better after they replaced your rg6 feed to cat5e sp2d  ?? (i bet it was the same ) :smileytongue:)
 
 bad cable = bad cable  wether it be cat5e or coax  both have to be terminated correctly...
 
pros and cons to both cables and should be used in the proper application ..
 
for most homes one or the other or both is fine imho  (standard disclaimer apply to zip 084  lol )
 
 
my take
randy
spd2demun
Posts: 22,101
Kudos: 376
Registered: ‎07-28-2007
My Device: ♥ U-verse! NOT~AN~EMPLOYEE!
Re: Coax or Cat-5 Installation?
I couldn't resist, as I knew it would get your dander up... :smileywink: 
From 084,
Home of the UFO!
 
smiley edit


Message Edited by spd2demun on 01-26-2008 10:40 PM
*The views and opinions expressed on this forum are purely my own. Any product claim, statistic, quote, or other representation about a product or service should be verified with the manufacturer, provider, or party.
Professor
randyl
Posts: 8,146
Registered: ‎10-25-2007
Re: Coax or Cat-5 Installation?
not so much my dander as the fact people read this stuff and spend money maybe when they dont need to imho
 
 
 
randy
Visitor
elob9
Posts: 25
Registered: ‎12-17-2007
Re: Coax or Cat-5 Installation?
I wasnt knocking coax
 I said  I liked cat5 for furture upgrades( more and more things are going to use ethernet) and that it was home ran to the rg not one feed split at diffent places all over the house
Visitor
elob9
Posts: 25
Registered: ‎12-17-2007
Re: Coax or Cat-5 Installation?
Im done posting here , you people need to grow up
Professor
randyl
Posts: 8,146
Registered: ‎10-25-2007
Re: Coax or Cat-5 Installation?


elob9 wrote:
the benifit of using cat5 is for future up grading and its faster to trouble shoot ( no spliters all ran to the rg in most cases) coax is half duplex cat5 is full duplex, the coax would have alot of collisions. computer networks years ago used them


          so now your  all mad cause i pointed out the fact coax doesnt cause collisions ????
          it that doesnt reek of dont use coax i dont know what does elob ??
          if u would read up  on hpna v3 u would see the benefits of it imho.. 
          aka  hpna v3 can go 600m and cat 5 only 100m   (distance) of course your mileage may vary..
          sorry u took it all personal but u are flat wrong u did knock it  imho
           like i said pros and cons to both cat 5 and coax in the at&t iptv system imho 
 
         randy
spd2demun
Posts: 22,101
Kudos: 376
Registered: ‎07-28-2007
My Device: ♥ U-verse! NOT~AN~EMPLOYEE!
Re: Coax or Cat-5 Installation?
I've seen randyl's stats and his all-coax is perfect; my house, it's a totally different story.  I'm now a mix, but probably more people have coax than Cat5 and are doing just fine with their service.  There have been people who have posted who are all Cat5 and that doesn't eliminate all problems either.  IMO each residence is unique. :smileywink:
*The views and opinions expressed on this forum are purely my own. Any product claim, statistic, quote, or other representation about a product or service should be verified with the manufacturer, provider, or party.